LITERARY SUSPENSE / Sarah Waters
I trusted no one in this book, myself included.
In Victorian London, a young thief is sent into a gloomy country house to help swindle an heiress. Waters builds a Dickensian world of forgers, madhouses and forbidden libraries, and a plot that refuses to sit still.

Lights out
The night it started
I started Fingersmith on a night when I was too tired to commit to anything long, which is a funny thing to say about a book that runs well past five hundred pages. I thought I'd read the first chapter to get the feel of it. The first chapter is Lant Street, in the Borough, in 1862, and the feel of it is so thick, so full of coal smoke and stolen goods and babies being minded for money, that I was a hundred pages in before the tea had properly cooled.
The hook
Sue Trinder has grown up in Mrs Sucksby's house among thieves and fences, a household where a locksmith turns stolen keys into money downstairs and nobody asks where anything came from. One night a smooth-talking con man everyone calls Gentleman arrives with a proposal. He wants Sue to go into service as a lady's maid to Maud Lilly, a young heiress living with her strange uncle at a remote country house called Briar. Gentleman means to marry Maud and get her fortune, and Sue is to help him do it and take a share.
That is the setup, and it is all I am willing to say about the plot. Sarah Waters builds this book in three parts, and the seams between them are where everything happens. If anyone ever tries to tell you about the end of part one, leave the room.
What kept the lamp on
The first pull is Sue's voice. She narrates with a Borough sharpness, quick and practical, wary of every gentleman and every lady, and completely sure she knows how the world works. It is a wonderful voice to spend a night inside, and Waters gives her a tremendous eye for texture. The dark corridors of Briar, the dusty quiet, the uncle's library with its forbidden shelves and its strict, joyless routines all arrive through someone who has never been anywhere so silent.
The second pull is Maud. She is pale, gloved, closely managed, kept to a timetable by her uncle, and she is either far more fragile or far more interesting than Sue first thinks. The scenes between the two of them alone in Maud's rooms, dressing and undressing, a small business with a silver thimble and a sharp tooth, are some of the most charged pages I have read in a long time. Waters writes desire as a kind of suspense. Every touch might mean something or nothing, and nobody in the room can say which out loud.
It is a book about being handled, and it handled me beautifully.
The third pull is structural, and it is the reason the light was still on at 3:36. Waters is playing a long game with the reader's assumptions. Somewhere around one in the morning I put the book face down on the duvet and simply stared at the ceiling for a while, recalibrating. Then I picked it back up, because there was no way I was going to sleep without knowing what came next. That happened more than once. The book keeps doing it, and it keeps working.
A little friction
The middle section slows in places. After the propulsion of part one, there is a stretch that goes back over familiar ground from a different angle, and while it is clever, and eventually essential, there were pages where I felt the pace thicken. Waters also loves her Victorian furniture, and occasionally the scenery crowds the scene. These are small complaints about a novel that is otherwise built like a very fine lock.
Who should read it, and when
Anyone who loves Dickens and wishes he had been less sentimental and more dangerous. Anyone who likes a long, immersive historical novel with real momentum. Start it on a Friday. Do not start it on a work night unless you have made peace with the consequences, and whatever you do, don't read the back of a later edition or a summary online before you begin.
Last thought before lights-out
When I finally turned the lamp off I lay there thinking about gloves. About how much of this novel is about hands, and what they take, and what they give. Somewhere in the dark the pieces were still moving, and I let them.