GOTHIC FICTION / Silvia Moreno-Garcia
The mould at High Place followed me upstairs.
In 1950s Mexico, glamorous Noemí Taboada travels to a decaying mansion in the mountains after an alarming letter from her newly married cousin. Moreno-Garcia gives the classic gothic a sharp, unsettling new house to haunt.

Lights out
The night it started
I started Mexican Gothic on a damp night, which in hindsight was a mistake. The radiator was ticking, the window had a faint film of condensation in one corner, and I had a mug of tea going lukewarm beside the lamp. By the second chapter I was looking at that corner of the window with a suspicion I could not quite justify.
The book opens in Mexico City in 1950, at a party. Noemí Taboada is twenty-two, rich, funny, a little spoiled, fond of cocktails and good dresses, and more serious than she lets on: she wants to study anthropology. Her father calls her away from the party to show her a letter from her cousin Catalina, recently married to an Englishman named Virgil Doyle. The letter is disordered and frightened. Something is wrong in the house. Noemí agrees to go and see.
What the book does
The house is High Place, a mansion in the mountains above a small former mining town called El Triunfo. The Doyles built their fortune on silver and brought their English ways with them: their furniture, their rules, even, it seems, their soil. The house is cold, the wallpaper is blooming with damp, the electricity is barely used, and conversation at dinner is not allowed.
Silvia Moreno-Garcia knows the gothic tradition inside out, and she plays its pieces with real wit. There is a vast decaying house, a sick young bride, a forbidding older woman who keeps the household in order, a mild and kind young man who seems out of place, and an ancient patriarch, Howard Doyle, who talks to her about heredity and bloodlines in a way that made my skin crawl. What makes it new is who walks into that house. Noemí is not a timid governess. She smokes, she argues, she notices when she is being condescended to, and she is quick to understand that the Doyles' interest in her face and her ancestry is not polite curiosity.
I kept reading because Noemí kept refusing to be quiet, and the house plainly did not like it.
Why the lamp stayed on
The pull is atmosphere first. Moreno-Garcia writes rot beautifully: the mould creeping up the walls, the fog that sits on the hills, the cemetery among the trees, the rooms lit by oil lamps and candles because the electricity is rationed. Noemí's sleep starts to go strange, and the dream sequences are hazy and sensual and wrong in a way that is hard to shake off at 2 AM. I read one of them and then sat very still, listening to the house I was actually in.
The second pull is Noemí's mind. Every chapter she adds to her understanding, visits the doctor in town, asks a local healer about Catalina, presses the family on their past, and every chapter the Doyles push back. The book is built like a slow pincer. You can feel it closing, and you want to know what it is closing on. I will not say. The answer is strange and thoroughly earned, and the less you know going in, the better it lands.
A little friction
The first third moves slowly, and if you are not already in love with crumbling houses you may wonder when it will get going. The last stretch, by contrast, is loud and fast and more overtly horror than the rest, which I loved at three in the morning but which some readers may find a sharp change in key. I also wanted a little more of Francis, the gentle young Doyle, whose quiet scenes with Noemí are some of the best in the book.
Who should read it, and when
Read it on a wet night in autumn. Read it if you love Rebecca and Jane Eyre but have always wished the heroine would answer back. Do not read it if you have just found a patch of damp in your bathroom.
Last thought before lights-out
At 3:03 I closed the book and turned off the lamp, and the corner of the window was still fogged. I told myself it was the radiator. I kept telling myself that until I was asleep.